| Broadway Play | The Coast of Utopia |
| Off-Broadway Play | Indian Blood |
| Play Revival | Journey's End |
| Actor in a Play | Frank Langella, Frost/Nixon |
| Actress in a Play | Eve Best, A Moon for the Misbegotten |
| Featured Actor in a Play | Boyd Gaines, Journey's End |
| Featured Actress in a Play | Martha Plimpton, The Coast of Utopia |
| Director of a Play | Jack O'Brien, The Coast of Utopia |
| Broadway Musical | Spring Awakening |
| Off-Broadway Musical | In the Heights |
| Revival of a Musical | Company |
| Actor in a Musical | Raul Esparza, Company |
| Actress in a Musical | Donna Murphy, LoveMusik |
| Featured Actor in a Musical | David Pittu, LoveMusik |
| Featured Actress in a Musical | Karen Ziemba, Curtains |
| Director of a Musical | Michael Mayer, Spring Awakening |
| Choreography | Andy Blankenbuehler, In the Heights |
| Set Design | Bob Crowley and Scott Pask, The Coast of Utopia |
| Costume Design | Catherine Zuber, The Coast of Utopia |
| Lighting Design | Brian MacDevitt, Kenneth Posner, and Natasha Katz, The Coast of Utopia |
| Solo Performance | Nilaja Sun, No Child . . . |
| John Gassner Playwrighting Award | Nilaja Sun, No Child . . . |
| New Score | Spring Awakening |
