| Broadway Play | The History Boys |
| Off-Broadway Play | Stuff Happens |
| Play Revival | Awake and Sing! |
| Actor in a Play | Gabriel Byrne, A Touch of the Poet |
| Actress in a Play | Lois Smith, The Trip to Bountiful |
| Featured Actor in a Play | Richard Griffiths, The History Boys |
| Featured Actress in a Play | Frances de la Tour, The History Boys |
| Director of a Play | Nicholas Hytner, The History Boys |
| Broadway Musical | Jersey Boys |
| Off-Broadway Musical | Grey Gardens |
| Revival of a Musical | Sweeney Todd |
| Actor in a Musical | John Lloyd, Young Jersey Boys |
| Actress in a Musical | Christine Ebersole, Grey Gardens |
| Featured Actor in a Musical | Jim Dale, The Threepenny Opera |
| Featured Actress in a Musical | Beth Leavel, The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Director of a Musical | John Doyle, Sweeney Todd |
| Choreography | Kathleen Marshall, The Pajama Game |
| Set Design | David Gallo, The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Costume Design | Gregg Barnes, The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Lighting Design | Howell Binkley, Jersey Boys |
| Solo Performance | Antony Sher, Primo |
| John Gassner Playwrighting Award | Danai Gurira & Nikkole Salter, In the Continuum |
| New Score | The Drowsy Chaperone, Music and Lyrics by Lisa Lambert and Greg Morrison |
