First Round (Nov. 17)
| at Augustana 54 | Defiance 14 |
| Wittenberg 38 | OT | at Hardin-Simmons 35 |
| at Thomas More 34 | MacMurray 30 |
| Pacific Lutheran 27 | OT | at Whitworth 26 |
| at WI-Stevens Point 37 | Bethel 27 |
| at St. John's (Minn.) 27 | St. Norbert 20 |
| Ithaca 35 | at Montclair St. 23 |
| at Rowan 40 | SUNY Brockport 17 |
| W. Connecticut St. 8 | at Westfield St. 7 |
| at Trinity 30 | Mary Hardin-Baylor 6 |
| at Wash. & Jeff. 24 | Western Maryland 21 |
| at Widener 56 | Christopher Newport 7 |
Second Round (Nov. 24)
| at Mount Union 32 | Augustana 7 |
| Wittenberg 41 | at Thomas More 0 |
| Pacific Lutheran 27 | OT | at Central (Iowa) 21 |
| at St. John's 9 | WI-Stevens Point 7 |
| Ithaca 27 | at Rensselaer 10 |
| at Rowan 43 | W. Connecticut St. 14 |
| at Bridgewater (Va.) 41 | Trinity 37 |
| at Widener 46 | Wash. & Jeff. 30 |
Quarterfinals (Dec. 1)
| at Mount Union 49 | Wittenberg 21 |
| at St. John's 31 | Pacific Lutheran 6 |
| at Rowan 48 | Ithaca 0 |
| at Bridgewater 57 | Widener 32 |
Semifinals (Dec. 8)
| at Mount Union 35 | St. John's 14 |
| at Bridgewater 29 | Rowan 24 |
Amos Alonzo Stagg Bowl
Dec. 15 at Salem, Va. (Att: 7,992)
| Mount Union 30 | Bridgewater 27 |
| (14-0) | (12-1) |
