The NCAA Division I players cited most frequently by the following All-America selectors: AP, U.S. Basketball Writers, National Assn. of Basketball Coaches and Wooden Award Committee. (*) indicates unanimous first team selection. Holdover from 1999-2000 first team in bold type.
First Team
| | Class | Hgt | Pos |
|---|
| Shane Battier*, Duke | Sr. | 6-8 | F |
| Troy Murphy*, Notre Dame | Jr. | 6-11 | F |
| Casey Jacobsen, Stanford | So. | 6-6 | F |
| Jason Williams*, Duke | So. | 6-2 | G |
| Joseph Forte, N. Carolina | So. | 6-4 | G |
Second Team
| | Class | Hgt | Pos |
|---|
| Michael Bradley, Villanova | Jr. | 6-10 | F |
| Jason Richardson, Michigan St. | So. | 6-6 | F |
| Jamaal Tinsley, Iowa St. | Sr. | 6-3 | G |
| Troy Bell, Boston College | So. | 6-1 | G |
| Tayshaun Prince, Kentucky | Jr. | 6-9 | G |
Third Team
| | Class | Hgt | Pos |
|---|
| Kirk Haston, Indiana | Jr. | 6-10 | F |
| Udonis Haslem, Florida | Jr. | 6-8 | C |
| Charlie Bell, Michigan St. | Sr. | 6-3 | G |
| Frank Williams, Illinois | So. | 6-3 | G |
| Juan Dixon, Maryland | Jr. | 6-3 | G |
